Pumpkin tends to get a lot of the Fall baking attention. But apples are going to be the star of the show here with these chewy apple cider cookies. Make these cookies with a spiced apple cider reduction, diced Granny Smith apples, and plenty of cinnamon and nutmeg. Instead of an apple cider donut this Fall reach for an apple cider cookie!

COOKIE INGREDIENTS
Here’s what you need to make these apple cider cookies!
- Apple cider. You’ll reduce this into 1/4 cup, any brand apple cider will work.
- Apples. Go for Granny Smith so that they retain some crispness even after baking.
- Sugars. Dark brown and white. I always use dark brown sugar because I like the extra depth of color you get compared to light brown sugar.
- Spices. Cinnamon and nutmeg.
- Butter. I always use salted butter. You’ll make brown butter for these cookies.
- Extras. Vanilla extract, salt, baking, soda, an egg.
- Slurry. Mixing a bit of cornstarch with water creates a “slurry”. You will need this in the apple cider reduction to help it get a bit thicker and not stay so watery.

HOW TO MAKE AN APPLE CIDER REDUCTION
The star of this cookie is the apple cider reduction. It’s easy to make, but you do need to keep an eye on it as it’s simmering to prevent bubbling over or burning. Here’s how to make it.
- Step 1. Make the slurry. Combine the water and cornstarch in a small dish. Pour the apple cider into a medium-sized pot, and whisk in the slurry. Heat over medium heat.
- Step 2. Once the apple cider has come to a bubbly simmer, simmer over medium heat for 25 – 30 minutes. Do not completely walk away from it, you need to keep an eye on it that it doesn’t bubble up towards the end or reduce too much and start to burn.
- Step 3. After 30 minutes, turn off heat. Mix in the cinnamon, and pour out 1/4 cup. You should have exactly 1/4 cup but if you have a bit more just set that aside, do not mix any extra into the cookie.


HOW TO MAKE BROWN BUTTER
Now that you’ve made your apple cider reduction it’s time to make the brown butter. Using brown butter instead of just melted or softened butter will add an extra layer of rich flavor and will help give a deeper golden color to the cookies.
First. Add the butter to a pot and melt over low heat. After the butter has fully melted, adjust the heat up to medium/medium high to get the butter simmering. The butter will go from melted, to lightly bubbly, then rapidly bubbling and finally a bit foamy. As you’re constantly whisking you’ll be able to see the browning begin to happen at the bottom of the pot.
Next. You’ll hear the rapid bubbling simmer but as the milk particles separate and you get the more foamy appearance it actually gets a bit quite. Stir constantly so that the milk particles don’t burn to the bottom of the pot.
Last. After 4-5 minutes the butter will be browned. Once this stage is reached you’ll want to immediately pour it into a heat proof bowl so the cooking process stops. Brown butter can go to burned butter pretty quickly, so you want to watch it closely and move quickly!

COOKIE BAKING TIPS AND QUESTIONS
- Do I need to reduce the apple cider? Yes! Do not skip this, or simply mix in 1/4 of apple cider. The reduction is creating a much more intense apple cider flavor and with the addition of the slurry it’s giving it a little extra thickness. Just mixing in straight apple cider won’t give you the right look, texture, or flavor.
- Can I use apple juice instead of cider? No! You need to use cider here. Cider and traditional apple juice aren’t equal substations for each other. Apple cider has a fuller apple flavor, and not as filtered as juice. It can also be spiced a bit more. Read more about the difference between juice and cider.
- I have more than 1/4 cup of the reduction, can I mix it in? No! With cookies you have to be so precise when it comes to mixing in liquids into the dough. Too much water or moisture will make a more cakey cookie and that’s not at all how I like my cookies. If you have a little more than the 1/4 cup reduction just set it aside and use it on top of ice cream, on pancakes or waffles in place of syrup, or dip the cookies in them.
- Do I need to use Granny Smith? You don’t have to, but I do recommend it. Granny Smith is really ideal for baking because they are super crisp, and don’t break down or get mushy like other apple types can. So you can use your preferred apple type here, but for apple pieces that still have a bit of crunch definitely go Granny Smith.
- How long should I bake these? So this is going to depend on what type of cookie texture you want. For firmer more traditional cookie texture bake 12 minutes. If you want a super gooey fudgy type cookie bake for 10-11 minutes. The extra juices that release from the apple cookies really help keep these soft baked and even give that “fudge” top appearance.

STORAGE INSTRUCTIONS
You can store the cookies covered on the counter at room temperature for 2 days. After that, pop them in the fridge to keep them fresh. Since there’s that extra moisture from the apples they will need to be chilled after 2 days to prevent spoiling.
If you’ve got some stored in the fridge, before eating them you can set them on the counter so they come back to room temperate. Or, my favorite way to enjoy them is to pop them in the microwave for 6-7 seconds for that gooey straight from the oven texture.

Ready for more apple baking? Here are some more apple recipes to try.
Apple crisp cookies
Caramelized apples
Apple cinnamon scones
Pumpkin apple muffins
Chewy Apple Cider Cookies
Soft and chewy cookies made with an apple cider reduction and loaded with diced Granny Smith apples and plenty of cinnamon.
- Prep Time: 35 minutes
- Cook Time: 11 minutes
- Total Time: 46 minutes
- Yield: 19 – 20 cookies
- Category: Cookies
- Method: Baking
- Cuisine: American
Ingredients
For the apple cider reduction
1 and 1/4 cup apple cider
1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon cornstarch
1/2 teaspoon water
For the cookie dough
1 and 1/2 cup all purpose flour
1 stick salted butter, browned
1 cup diced Granny Smith apples (skin removed)
3/4 cup dark brown sugar
1/2 cup white sugar
1 egg
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 teaspoon cinnamon
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
Instructions
1. Make the apple cider reduction. Combine the water and corn starch in a small bowl. To a medium-sized pot add the apple cider then whisk in the water + cornstarch. Heat over medium heat until a bubbly simmer. Simmer for 25 – 30 minutes until the mixture is reduced to 1/4 cup. Keep an eye on this as it can bubble up as it reduces. In the last 5 minutes watch closely to prevent burning, reduce heat if necessary. After it’s reduced remove from heat and mix in the 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon. If you have more than 1/4 cup after 30 minutes, just set aside any extra but do not mix into the cookie dough.
2. Wipe clean this pot, then brown the butter. Add the stick of butter to the medium-sized pot over medium heat, then add the butter. After the butter is melted adjust the heat higher to medium-high. Allow the butter to come to a rapid bubbly simmer. While adjusting the heat between medium and medium-high, continually stir the butter until the milk particles have browned and the liquid is a rich caramel or amber color. I’ve found that once the butter is melted this process takes 4-5 minutes. Once fully browned, immediately turn off heat and pour into a heat proof bowl.
3. In a large bowl, combine the flour, cinnamon, nutmeg, baking soda, and salt.
4. To the brown butter, whisk in the brown sugar, then the white sugar, egg, vanilla, and lastly the 1/4 cup apple cider reduction.
5. Add the dry ingredients into the wet and stir to combine, adding in the diced apples and stirring to fully incorporate into the dough.
6. Chill dough for 20 minutes. When there’s about 10 minutes left on the chill time, preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
7. How to bake the cookies. Form the cookie dough balls and bake. For a firmer set cookie with crisper edges, bake 12-13 minutes. For a soft and gooey cookie bake for 11 minutes (they will be quite soft). The apple pieces will release some juices giving the tops of the cookies a fudgy look. I recommend baking 1-2 cookies first at your desired length of time before baking them all to reach the texture you want. I like a very soft cookie, so I did 11 minutes.
